Tuesday, November 4, 2014

Hate Crime

A hate crime is defined as a crime motivated by racial, sexual, or other prejudice, typically involving violence.  Although there is controversy, the murder of Matthew Shepard points directly towards a hate crime.  There are many witnesses and pieces of evidence that help prove this event as a hate crime, not a drug deal gone bad.  For example, the bar tender said that Matthew Shepard was minding his own business and wasn’t trying to hit on anyone.  Aaron Mckinny and Russell Henderson though, pretended to be gay in the bar and hit on Shepard.  Why else would one pretend to be gay to hit on another gay person besides to deceive that person into doing what one wants.  One of the arguments against this being a hate crime is that Mckinny and Henderson were trying to rob Shepard.  This doesn’t add up because they didn’t need to drive Shepard way out into the countryside, tie him to a fence and beat him close to death just to take his shoes and wallet with barely any cash in it.  Another argument is that Mckinny and Henderson did what they did out of meth induced rage.  Why would they pick Matthew Shepard to murder, out of all other people in the bar? There had been no altercations between them before that could be used as a motive to murder Shepard.  This evidence strongly supports that Matthew Shepard was killed only because he was homosexual. 

The Laramie Project was not created or arranged to show that the murder of Matthew Shepard was a hate crime, but to show the raw perspectives of many different people of Laramie towards the murder or how Shepard was related to them.  Moisés Kaufman does a powerful job at arranging the non-fictional interviews in a creative way that allows one to form their own belief about the subject.  During the moment Matthew, different views and characteristics are said about Shepard.  Kaufman put this moment in the beginning of the book because it lays out the background of Matthew Shepard that can be used for the rest of the book.  Different people portray Matthew Shepard in several ways in this moment.  Romaine Patterson, one of the interviewers, said, “And whenever I think of Matthew, I always think of his incredible beaming smile.”  This portrays Shepard as a loving and inviting to everyone.  Shepard is also seen to be strong in his beliefs, despite that he is in a place that does not except change well.  Jon Peacock, Shepard’s academic advisor, remembers Shepard saying, “…there are opportunities here. There are things I can do in this world. I can be Important.”  This shows that Shepard was determined and not afraid to be who he is, even in an isolated place like Laramie.  The arrangement of the interviews gives the play the creativity aspect, and allows the reader to make their own conclusions.                                     
                


                     

No comments:

Post a Comment